Read the related blogpost here
0:00
Welcome to the deep dive today.
0:02
We're gonna be tackling your research on phonics education.
0:06
You've given us excerpts from seven research papers and reports.
0:09
A real treasure trove our mission today to unearth the most important nuggets about phonics instruction and see what they mean for those learning to read and spoiler alert.
0:22
We'll uncover a surprising stat from a global study that might make you rethink how effective phonics can be in certain countries.
0:30
Very interesting.
0:31
I'm excited about this one.
0:33
Yeah, me too.
0:34
I'm excited to connect the dots between all these meta analyses and on the ground reports and you know, everything in between.
0:40
There's always something new to discover when you bring diverse sources together.
0:44
Absolutely.
0:45
Ok.
0:45
Before we jump into the latest research, let's rewind a bit.
0:47
I noticed in two of 4038 dot PDFs, there's a fascinating back story about how phonics instruction has evolved over time, especially in the UK.
0:56
What can you tell us about that?
0:58
Well, it's like phonics itself has gone through a learning curve.
1:01
The UK used to favor analytic phonics where you start with whole words and break them down into sounds but they eventually shifted towards synthetic phonics which builds words up from individual sounds like sounding out each letter and blending them together.
1:16
So instead of starting with the whole picture of the word, they switch to focusing on the individual building blocks of sounds, it makes you wonder what triggered that shift and what the implications were for reading instruction.
1:29
Yeah, that's a question researchers have been grappling with for decades.
1:33
Really?
1:34
Oh, yeah.
1:34
And that historical context really sets the stage for understanding where we are today.
1:39
Speaking of which have you ever come across the simple view of reading?
1:43
I have.
1:44
It's a model that's become quite influential in the field.
1:47
Yeah, it emphasizes the importance of both decoding skills, which is that phonics piece we've been talking about and language comprehension, understanding what those words and sentences actually mean makes sense that you need both to truly grasp what you're reading exactly.
2:04
And that's a crucial point to keep in mind as we delve deeper into your research.
2:09
Now, let's get to the heart of the matter.
2:10
How effective is phonics instruction?
2:13
One of your sources, the National reading panel's meta analysis from national reading panel dot PDF sheds light on that.
2:20
I'm ready for those key takeaways from what I've skimmed.
2:24
It seems like systematic phonics instruction really does make a difference.
2:27
But I'm curious about the specifics.
2:29
You're on the right track.
2:30
The national reading panel found that systematic phonics instruction not only improves reading skills significantly, but consistently outperforms approaches that are less structured or don't include phonics at all.
2:43
And this isn't just a general observation, they analyzed a huge pool of studies to reach that conclusion.
2:49
So it's not just about teaching phonics randomly, it's about having a specific plan and sequence that makes me think about how teachers actually implement these findings in their classrooms.
3:01
That's where things get really interesting because translating research into practice is its own puzzle.
3:06
But before we get into the nitty gritty of implementation, let's explore a few more fascinating tidbits from that national reading panel report.
3:15
For instance, they found that starting phonics instruction early, ideally in kindergarten or first grade leads to the most significant benefits before those independent reading skills have really taken root.
3:26
Exactly.
3:27
That makes sense.
3:27
It's about laying a strong foundation from the very beginning.
3:30
Precisely.
3:31
But hold is more, more.
3:33
The report also highlights how phonics benefits struggling readers of various ages.
3:37
Oh, interesting.
3:38
Yeah, it gives them the tools to decode words and unlock the magic of reading regardless of their starting point.
3:44
That's encouraging to hear.
3:46
It reinforces the idea that it's never too late to strengthen those decoding skills.
3:50
Exactly.
3:51
And here's another interesting finding that caught my eye phonics instruction can actually boost spelling skills, especially in the younger grades.
3:58
Ok.
3:59
That's a connection I hadn't really considered before.
4:01
It highlights how intertwined reading and writing are and how phonics can support both right.
4:06
But I have to ask, we've been talking about phonics in general.
4:11
But what about that debate between synthetic and analytic phonics?
4:16
One of the reports seed seven year report dot PDF really seem to dig into that particularly in the UK context and a systematic review of the research literature.
4:26
L N dot PDF takes a broader research perspective on this debate.
4:30
So cut to the chase is one approach demonstrably superior.
4:35
If only it were that simple based purely on reading accuracy, the evidence doesn't definitively favor one over the other.
4:42
However, the seed report does highlight a fascinating study, girls who received either synthetic or analytic phonics but also had phonemic awareness training, actually outperformed those who received only analytic phonics.
4:55
And this advantage persisted even 15 months after the instruction ended.
4:58
Hold on a second, you just introduced a new term phonemic awareness.
5:03
How is that different from phonics?
5:05
Fantastic question.
5:06
They're closely related but distinct phonemic awareness is the ability to hear and manipulate individual sounds in spoken words, it's like the auditory Foundation for Phonics.
5:18
So you can see how they work together.
5:20
That makes sense.
5:21
So in this study, the girls who have that extra boost of phonemic awareness, regardless of whether they had synthetic or analytic phonics ended up with a lasting advantage in their reading accuracy.
5:34
Exactly.
5:35
And that's a crucial insight because it suggests that combining these approaches could be a recipe for success.
5:40
Well, let's not forget accuracy.
5:42
Is only one piece of the reading puzzle, right.
5:45
Fluency and comprehension matter too.
5:47
Absolutely.
5:47
Decoding a word is just the first step.
5:50
Need to be able to read it smoothly and effortlessly to truly comprehend what you're reading.
5:55
And isn't that what reading is all about understanding and enjoying those words and stories?
5:59
You hit the nail on the head.
6:01
The National reading channel's meta analysis describes fluency as a bridge between decoding and comprehension.
6:08
It's about reading smoothly and with expression which ultimately frees up your cognitive resources to focus on understanding the text.
6:16
So it's not just about speed reading, it's about making those words come alive.
6:20
It's the difference between a robot reading a text and someone telling you an engaging story precisely.
6:26
And the report suggests that fluency isn't just something that happens naturally.
6:31
It can be developed through targeted instruction, interesting, particularly what's called guided, repeated oral reading.
6:38
Ok.
6:38
I'm intrigued.
6:39
Yeah.
6:39
Can break down what guided repeated oral reading actually looks like in a classroom.
6:44
It involves having students read the same passage aloud multiple times with guidance and feedback from a teacher or tutor.
6:51
It's all about practice and getting comfortable with the flow of words.
6:55
So it's like rehearsing a play or practicing a musical instrument, the more you do it, the smoother and more expressive you become.
7:01
Exactly.
7:02
And the research suggests that programs promoting independent reading can also positively impact fluency and comprehension, which makes sense, the more you read the better you get at it.
7:14
That's a great point.
7:15
It highlights the importance of fostering a love of reading, not just drilling the mechanics.
7:20
Absolutely.
7:21
Now, we've explored the research behind Phonics, the nuances of different approaches and the crucial role of fluency.
7:28
But what about the real world implementation?
7:31
I'm sure you've encountered this in your own research.
7:33
How does all of this theory actually play out in classrooms?
7:38
That's the million dollar question, isn't it?
7:40
It seems like there's often a gap between what research recommends and what actually happens on the ground.
7:45
It does one of the reports he provided R 418 AIC screening check evaluation dot PDF hinted at some of the challenges teachers face.
7:54
Yeah, I notice that I'm eager to hear your take on that.
7:57
Well, let's dive into that in part two of our deep dives where we'll unravel those complexities and see what insights we can glean from teachers' experiences.
8:04
Sounds good.
8:05
That report R R 408 phonic screening check valuation dot PDF offers a glimpse into the disconnect between research and practice.
8:13
It found that less than 30% of literacy coordinators found a particular phonics screening check valuable.
8:20
They felt it didn't reveal anything they weren't already aware of.
8:24
That's fascinating.
8:26
So even though research highlights the importance of phonics, some educators aren't finding these assessments helpful.
8:32
Makes you wonder if there's a communication gap between researchers and those on the front lines of education, it's a crucial point.
8:39
While research can provide valuable guidance, it's essential to consider the complexities of real world implementation and the perspectives of teachers makes sense.
8:49
After all, they're the ones working with students day in and day out.
8:52
It's like we're piecing together a puzzle with research practice and those on the ground experiences all fitting together to create the complete picture.
9:01
But before we get too lost in the weeds, let's zoom out and gain a global perspective.
9:06
The P I L S 2021 2021 international results in reading dot PDF offers fascinating insights into reading achievement around the world.
9:16
Yeah, remember that surprising statistic I teased earlier.
9:19
Well, here it is, Singapore had over one third of its fourth graders reaching the advanced international benchmark in reading their educational system and their approach to phonics are certainly worth examining.
9:31
I'm all ears.
9:32
What makes their system so effective?
9:34
Are they using some revolutionary phonics method?
9:36
We haven't heard of?
9:37
Well, while the P I S study doesn't delve into specific methods, their success likely stems from a combination of factors.
9:46
One key element could be their strong emphasis on early literacy skills.
9:51
Got you.
9:51
They invest heavily in early childhood education, ensuring Children enter school with a solid grasp of language and pre reading skills.
9:59
So it's not just about phonics instruction and isolation, but about creating a comprehensive literacy environment from the very beginning, right?
10:06
It's like building a house.
10:09
You need that strong foundation to support everything else precisely.
10:13
It's about nurturing a love of language, developing that phonemic awareness we talked about and providing rich opportunities for oral language development.
10:22
These early experiences lay the groundwork for success with phonics.
10:26
Later on that makes perfect sense.
10:29
What else can we learn from their approach?
10:31
Their highly structured and systematic approach to teaching is another factor worth considering.
10:36
They have a clear curriculum progression, carefully sequenced skills and a strong emphasis on teacher training and professional development.
10:44
So it's not just about throwing a bunch of phonics worksheets at kids.
10:48
It's about having a well defined roadmap and equipping teachers with the knowledge and skills to deliver effective lessons, right?
10:55
It sounds like a multi faceted approach, not a quick fix.
10:58
Absolutely.
10:59
And remember, they don't just focus on phonics and isolation.
11:03
They understand the importance of a balanced literacy program, incorporating vocabulary development, reading comprehension strategies and exposure to a wide variety of texts.
11:12
It goes back to that literacy toolbox analogy.
11:15
It's about having a diverse set of tools to meet the needs of all learners.
11:19
But I want to circle back to something we touched on earlier that potential disconnect between research and practice.
11:26
What are your thoughts on how we can bridge that gap?
11:29
Well, we know from the research that systematic phonics instruction is effective yet some teachers are finding certain assessments and approaches less than helpful.
11:40
This suggests a need for more open dialogue and collaboration between researchers and practitioners.
11:46
I couldn't agree more.
11:48
It's about bridging that gap and creating a more symbiotic relationship where research informs practice and practice informs research.
11:57
But how do we actually make that happen?
11:59
We need to find ways to translate research findings into practical teacher friendly strategies that can be readily implemented in diverse classroom settings.
12:08
And we need to create spaces for teachers to share their experiences, challenges and insights so researchers can or understand the realities of on the ground implementation.
12:18
It's about recognizing the teachers are the experts in their classrooms and their knowledge and perspectives are invaluable.
12:25
What are some concrete steps we can take to foster that dialogue and collaboration, professional development opportunities that bring researchers and teachers together for meaningful conversations about phonics instruction are a great starting point, think workshops, conferences or even online forums where teachers can share their experiences and ask researchers questions directly.
12:46
I love that idea.
12:47
It's about breaking down those silos and creating a more collaborative learning environment, but it's not just about talking to each other, right?
12:54
It's also about creating resources and tools that are accessible and relevant to both researchers and teachers.
13:01
Exactly.
13:02
We need concise user friendly resources that distill research findings into practical strategies.
13:08
This could involve developing practical guides, instructional videos or interactive online modules that break down complex concepts into manageable chunks.
13:18
I'm picturing something like a phonics toolkit for teachers packed with evidence based strategies and real world examples.
13:24
It's about making research more accessible and empowering teachers to become informed consumers of that research.
13:30
Exactly.
13:31
And it's not just about the content, it's about the research process itself.
13:35
We need to ensure that studies are designed to be relevant to practitioners, moving beyond isolated lab settings and conducting more research directly in classrooms in partnership with teachers would provide a more realistic understanding of how phonics instruction works in real world contexts.
13:54
It's about creating a more participatory research model where teachers have a voice and their perspectives are valued.
14:01
Absolutely.
14:02
And it's not just about researchers and teachers, right, parents and caregivers play a crucial role in supporting their children's literacy development.
14:09
How can we bring them into the conversation?
14:11
We can empower parents with knowledge and resources through workshops or online materials.
14:17
Explain the importance of phonics, offer practical tips for supporting phonics learning at home.
14:22
Got you and a common questions and concerns.
14:25
It's about creating a community of support around literacy where everyone works together to ensure all Children have the opportunity to become successful readers.
14:33
That's a beautiful vision.
14:34
And speaking of different perspectives, we've talked about the debate between synthetic and analytic phonics.
14:42
But is it really an either situation you're hitting on a key point?
14:47
It's important to remember that these approaches aren't mutually exclusive.
14:50
Many effective phonics programs incorporate elements of both.
14:54
It's not about choosing one over the other, but finding the right balance and integrating the best of both worlds.
15:01
So it's about being flexible and responsive.
15:03
Recognizing that different Children may benefit from different strategies.
15:08
Right?
15:08
It's not a one size fits all approach.
15:11
Exactly.
15:12
And we have to remember that phonics instruction is just one piece of the puzzle.
15:15
The PRS study highlighted that Singapore's success in reading isn't solely due to phonics.
15:21
It's also influenced by their strong educational system, emphasis on early childhood education, highly qualified teachers and supportive home environments.
15:31
It sounds like a holistic approach where everything works together to support literacy development.
15:36
What are your thoughts on the role technology plays in all of this?
15:39
We haven't touched on that yet, but it's an area that's rapidly evolving.
15:44
That's a great point and a perfect segue into the final part of our deep dive.
15:48
We'll explore the potential of technology to enhance phonics learning and create more engaging and accessible instruction for all learners.
15:57
It's amazing to think how technology is transforming every aspect of our lives, including education when it comes to phonics instruction.
16:05
I imagine the possibilities are endless.
16:08
Absolutely.
16:08
Technology can be a game changer, especially for something as foundational as phonics.
16:13
Think about it, personalized learning platforms can tailor instruction to each child's pace and needs providing instant feedback and adjusting the difficulty level as they progress.
16:23
Like having a virtual reading tutor available 24 7.
16:26
And speaking of engaging, I bet there are some amazing apps and programs out there that make learning phonics, fun and interactive you're spot on.
16:36
There are apps that turn phonics practice into games complete with colorful animation and catchy songs.
16:42
It's a far cry from those old school phonics drills I can imagine and don't forget about the power of digital story.
16:49
Oh, right.
16:50
Children can create their own stories, incorporating the phonics skills they're learning and even share them with others.
16:56
That's such a creative way to bring phonics to life.
16:58
It's not just about memorizing sounds, it's about using those sounds to express yourself and tell your own stories.
17:04
But let's not get carried away with all the bells and whistles.
17:07
At the end of the day, technology should be a tool to enhance learning, not a replacement for effective teaching, couldn't agree.
17:14
More technology can be incredibly powerful, but it's crucial to use it thoughtfully and intentionally, the goal is to supplement and support good teaching practices not to replace the human connection that's so vital in education.
17:28
So let's bring it all together.
17:30
We've explored a ton of information today about phonics instruction.
17:33
We've delved into the research, examined different approaches and even gained a global perspective.
17:38
What are some key takeaways our listeners can walk away with.
17:42
Well, first and foremost systematic phonics instruction is essential for developing strong reading skills.
17:48
The research is crystal clear on that point, but as we've discussed, it's not as simple as just teaching letter sounds effective phonics instruction involves careful planning intentional instruction and ongoing support for teachers.
18:02
And it's not just about phonics in isolation, we need to embed it within a balanced literacy program that also nurtures vocabulary development, reading comprehension strategies and a genuine love of reading.
18:13
Exactly.
18:14
And perhaps most importantly, we need to approach this work with a spirit of continuous learning and collaboration.
18:21
Research is constantly evolving and the best educators are always seeking to deepen their understanding and refine their practices.
18:28
It's about being open to new ideas, engaging in dialogue with colleagues and researchers and being willing to adapt our approaches based on what we learn.
18:37
It's a journey, not a destination well said.
18:40
And for those who want to continue exploring the full reports and research papers we referenced today are a great place to start.
18:47
They provide a wealth of in depth information and insights and don't forget about the many reputable organizations dedicated to literacy such as the International Literacy Association and Reading Rockets.
18:59
They offer a treasure trove of articles, videos and professional development opportunities and don't underestimate the power of connecting with other educators, whether it's through online forums, professional development workshops or simply chatting with colleagues, sharing experiences and ideas can be incredibly enriching.
19:15
Absolutely.
19:16
We're all in this together striving to empower young readers and unlock the world of literacy.
19:21
So as we wrap up this deep dive into phonics education, I'm going to leave our listeners with a final thought provoking question we've talked about global approaches and bridging the gap between research and practice.
19:31
But what would your ideal Phonics program look like?
19:36
What elements would you prioritize?
19:38
How would you balance those different approaches we discussed?
19:41
It's a great question to ponder as you continue your own exploration of phonics instruction.
19:46
And remember, the most effective approaches are those that are tailored to the unique needs of each learner.
19:51
We hope this deep dive has provided valuable insights and inspired you to continue your phonics journey.
19:56
Happy reading.
